Storing CO2 underground could trigger earthquakes

By Victoria Schlesinger

Stashing carbon dioxide underground is a much-debated approach to combating rising greenhouse gas levels, and is being tested in California, but is often criticized for its hefty price tag. Now, there may be another fatal flaw in carbon capture and storage. A new paper by Stanford University geophysicist Mark Zoback says the process would likely cause earthquakes that allow the gas to escape back into the atmosphere.

“Beyond economics,” wrote Zoback, “there is a potentially serious geological issue that threatens the viability of large scale CO2 sequestration, which may not be technically solvable, at any cost – the likelihood that injection of enormous volumes of CO2 into the subsurface will trigger intraplate earthquakes.”

Proponents of carbon capture and sequestration espouse collecting CO2 where it is produced, at coal-fired power plants for example, and then pumping the compressed gas into underground natural geologic formations, where it would be stored indefinitely. Over hundreds to thousands of years the CO2 would mineralize into calcium carbonate, also known as limestone.

There’s significant potential for storing CO2 in California, according to West Coast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (WESTCARB), a consortium of government agencies and energy companies funded by the DOE to investigate the technology’s potential statewide. They estimate there’s enough space in California to store 1,800 to 6,600 years’ worth of emissions produced by our current power plants.

WESTCARB worked for seven years to implement a carbon capture and storage pilot project in Solano County, but said they gave up this year for business reasons. They continue to pursue two larger projects in the Central Valley.

According to Zoback, sufficient evidence suggests that pumping huge volumes of the gas underground, as would be necessary to stem global warming, could cause small intraplate earthquakes. Most earthquakes occur at the boundary of two tectonic plates, while intraplate activity takes place along fissures within the plates.

He wrote, “While the seismic waves from such earthquakes might not directly threaten the public, small earthquakes at depth could threaten the integrity of a CO2 repositories, expected to store CO2 for periods of hundreds to thousands of years.”

In essence, the CO2 could escape, negating any environmental benefits promised by the expensive process. An abstract of Zoback’s paper was presented this week at the American Geophysical Union’s annual conference underway in San Francisco. WOW is in the process of obtaining the full paper.

Tags: , carbon capture and sequestration, carbon capture and storage, carbon dioxide geologic sequestration, ccs, , mark zoback, stanford university, westcarb

Comments are closed.

Featured Video

SF Environment Director Melanie Nutter talks about SF climate change policy at TEDx

Follow Us!

Recent Comments

emilia luxa: please watch and pass onto everyone you know...
emilia luxa: I just watched Leuren Moret speak on this and I believe that those reactors...
Susan Kocher: How can the CPUC allow the CEO of PG&E to walk away with even $1M much ...
boris_qd: But didn't they also get permission to raise rates in exchange for better r...
Ineke: Nuclear energy? NO THANKS!...
Alex: I agree that pg&e should have gotten their P.R. down. With all the news...
Alex: that example is not the same. have you ever read through a pg&e bill? h...
Alex: I agree that pg&e should have gotten their P.R. down. With all the news...
Alex: Have you read all the contracts? I think since the meter is owned by the co...

Field Notes Blog

French radiation organization says exposure risks are no longer negligible

Just as farmers markets are swinging into full bloom, there’s very disturbing news about radiation from Japan reaching new levels in Europe. And if...
Read more »

Super graph on normal and abnormal radiation exposures

Did you know that sleeping next to someone blitzes you with 0.05 millionth of a sievert of radiation per night? That eating a banana...
Read more »

UC Berkeley study: Using fear backfires on climate change

It’s been a point of maddening frustration for scientists and environmentalists that as the predictions on global warming grow more dire, the public seems...
Read more »

Got News?

Send story tips or news items for The Daily Catch:

[email protected]

We want to hear from you!

Who we are

Way Out West is a news site for the Bay Area dedicated to daily coverage of local green news.

We're camping out at public meetings, traipsing through parks, and sticking our noses into green tech research to bring you relevant local stories that matter.

WOW is produced by two local environmental journalists for you, our eco-savvy readers. We'd love to hear what you want from this site.